Don't Wait for the Election, Give Judge Garland a Chance
Not unlike when Obama dared them to shut down the government, the president has laid out another primrose path for Republicans in this election year. You don't have to be from a red planet to see that...
President Obama has them right where he wants them: Backs up against a wall of their own making. Immediately following the death of Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell declared there'd* be no hearings nor would a vote be held for an Obama-appointed replacement - Republicans would hunker down and wait for the election. They had enough problems just trying to field a viable presidential candidate.
Then that crafty president offered up and extolled the virtues of the most mild-mannered, qualified and reasonable of choices, Judge Merrick Garland. A middle-of-the-political-road candidate nowhere near the leftist-activist nightmare Republican Judiciary members were envisioning, and...surprise, surprise...a white male (that's how you know when Obama is just playing with his food).
- If the Republicans relent and come out of their shell, they'll have gone back on their word - this will likely dismay and fracture the hard right GOP voters desperately needed to win the presidential election. This is particularly true if the much reviled "true conservative" Cruz is the brokered nominee.
- If the Republicans hold fast, they give the Democrats great campaign fodder for the general electorate, who can plainly see what an appealing and almost non-partisan choice Merrick Garland clearly is. Meanwhile, the GOP's own voter enthusiasm wanes on this issue since the end result could well be a Hillary Clinton payback choice for all her über-progressive supporters, (or whatever libel-loving lawyer Trump would pick).
 |
| That's quite a pickle |
Here's the solution I'd propose
- First, hold out until the Democratic Convention, where the Dems will work themselves up into a lather saying Garland-is-God's-gift-to-jurisprudence (well, they won't actually use the word "God," Heaven forbid, but whatever the Progressive politically correct equivalent is this week)
- Then ease off a bit, agreeing to hold only meetings with all Republican Senators to get to know him, as a courtesy
- Finally, announce the Republicans will agree to discuss this and take action at the brokered Republican Convention in August
Then:
Declare Merrick Garland to be the Republican Nominee for President
No broken promises, no backing down
No Trump
No Cruz
Just a well-liked, Democratically-endorsed, alternative to Hillary
And then live with it. We could do so much worse.
* there'd = there would - it's a lovely contraction; I'm re-introducing it